Listen or watch on your favorite platforms
Episode Show Notes
Capt. Paul Tejera is a legendary fishing guide based in the Florida Keys with decades of experience on the water. A former college baseball player who became highly ranked in Florida tennis in his 20s before setting the sport aside for thirty years, Paul returned to the court at 63 and quickly climbed to second-ranked in the state in the 18-and-over 4.0 division, still competing against players in their 30s. In this conversation, Paul reveals the mindset shifts that allowed him to excel in multiple pursuits, the real estate strategy that changed his life in the Keys, and why the best guides never stop learning. You'll hear stories about legendary anglers, the evolution of Keys fishing, and the simple daily habits that keep Paul operating at peak performance decades into his career.
What Makes Capt. Paul Tejera a Legendary Florida Keys Fishing Guide?
Capt. Paul Tejera has guided in the Florida Keys for decades, building a reputation for consistency, adaptability, and a perpetually positive attitude on the water. His approach combines deep local knowledge with athletic discipline from his background in college baseball and competitive tennis, allowing him to excel across multiple pursuits including guiding, real estate, and kiteboarding before returning to competitive tennis at 63.
Who is Capt. Paul Tejera?
Capt. Paul Tejera is a Florida Keys fishing guide with decades of experience who played college baseball before becoming a highly ranked tennis player in Florida. After setting tennis aside for thirty years to focus on guiding, real estate, and kiteboarding, he returned to competitive tennis at age 63 and reached second-ranked in the state in the 18-and-over 4.0 division.
This episode is brought to you by Star brite, the marine care products that guides like Paul and Tom trust to keep their boats performing at their best in harsh saltwater conditions. When you're on the water as much as Paul has been over the decades, quality marine care isn't optional.
The Tennis Comeback That Defied Age
After thirty years away from competitive tennis, Paul Tejera picked up a racket at age 63 and did something most people would consider impossible. Within months, he was competing against players in their 30s and climbing the rankings in Florida's competitive 18-and-over 4.0 division. What makes this story remarkable isn't just the athletic achievement—it's the mindset Paul brought from decades of guiding and how he approached the comeback with zero expectations but complete commitment. He reveals the specific training approach he used, why he chose to compete in the 18-and-over division instead of age-appropriate brackets, and what playing against much younger opponents taught him about staying competitive in any field. The full story of Paul's tennis comeback starts early in the conversation.
Real Estate Strategy in the Florida Keys
Paul shares a candid look at how he approached real estate in the Keys, including decisions that paid off and lessons learned along the way. He talks about the timing of his moves, the market conditions he navigated, and why location matters differently in the Keys than other markets. There's a specific story about a property decision that changed his financial trajectory, and Paul doesn't hold back on the details of what he wishes he'd known earlier. For anyone interested in Keys real estate or how guides build financial stability beyond charter income, this section offers rare insider perspective from someone who's lived and worked in the market for decades. Paul's real estate insights unfold throughout the middle section of the episode.
Hear Paul explain how he climbed to second-ranked in Florida tennis at 63
The Evolution of Guiding in the Florida Keys
With decades on the water, Paul has witnessed dramatic changes in Keys fishing and the guiding profession. He discusses how the fishery has evolved, what's changed about client expectations, and how technology has transformed the way guides operate. There are stories about legendary anglers and guides Paul has fished with and learned from over the years, offering a window into the Keys fishing culture that most people never see. Paul also shares his perspective on what separates good guides from great ones, and it has less to do with fish-finding ability than you might think. His insights on maintaining a positive attitude regardless of conditions reveal why he's remained in demand for so many years. Paul's perspective on the evolution of Keys guiding runs throughout the conversation.
Get the Best Fishing & Outdoor Content
Weekly insights on fishing strategy, conservation, and the disciplines that transfer across pursuits.
SubscribeLessons from College Baseball and Multiple Pursuits
Paul's background as a college baseball player shaped how he approaches everything from guiding to real estate to his tennis comeback. He talks about the mental disciplines that transfer across different pursuits and why excelling in one area often makes you better at others. There's a deeper conversation here about focus, recovery, and knowing when to push versus when to back off—lessons Paul learned on the baseball field that he's applied on the water for decades. He also shares specific examples of how his athletic background prepared him for the physical and mental demands of full-time guiding in the Keys, including strategies for maintaining performance during long days and challenging conditions. Paul's insights on transferable lessons from athletics appear throughout the episode.
Don't miss this one.
A rare conversation with a Keys legend who's mastered multiple pursuits
Key Takeaways
- Paul Tejera returned to competitive tennis at 63 after a thirty-year hiatus and climbed to second-ranked in Florida's 18-and-over 4.0 division—the strategy behind this comeback applies far beyond tennis
- Decades of guiding in the Florida Keys taught Paul that attitude matters more than conditions, and there's a specific approach he uses to maintain positivity regardless of what's happening on the water
- Paul's real estate decisions in the Keys reveal timing lessons and market insights that only come from living and working in the same place for decades
- The mental disciplines from college baseball transferred directly to Paul's success as a guide, real estate investor, and competitive athlete—he shares exactly how these lessons apply
- What separates legendary Keys guides from everyone else has less to do with finding fish than you'd expect, and Paul's perspective on this comes from fishing alongside some of the best
- Paul added kiteboarding and other pursuits to his repertoire over the years, and his approach to learning new skills at any age offers a blueprint for staying engaged and improving
Final Thoughts from Tom
I've known Paul for years, and what strikes me most about him is that perpetual smile and positive energy. It doesn't matter what's happening—tough fishing, challenging conditions, whatever—Paul brings the same enthusiasm and optimism to every situation. That's rare, and it's made him one of the most sought-after guides in the Keys for decades.
What really got me in this conversation was hearing about his tennis comeback at 63. The fact that he walked away from the sport for thirty years, picked it back up, and within months was competing at a high level against guys in their 30s—that says everything about his mindset and work ethic. The lessons he shares about approaching a new challenge with zero expectations but complete commitment apply to fishing, business, and life in general.
Paul's insights on real estate, guiding, and maintaining peak performance over decades make this one worth listening to all the way through. Whether you're a guide, an angler, or someone trying to excel at multiple pursuits, you'll find something valuable here. This one's worth your time.
Frequently Asked Questions
How did Capt. Paul Tejera become a fishing guide in the Florida Keys?
Paul became a Florida Keys fishing guide after his college baseball career ended, building his reputation over decades through consistent performance, positive attitude, and deep local knowledge. He balanced guiding with real estate investments and other outdoor pursuits including kiteboarding throughout his career.
What is Capt. Paul Tejera's tennis ranking in Florida?
After returning to competitive tennis at age 63 following a thirty-year hiatus, Paul Tejera climbed to second-ranked in the state of Florida in the 18-and-over 4.0 division. He competes against players in their 30s and continues to train and compete at a high level.
What makes a legendary Florida Keys fishing guide?
According to Capt. Paul Tejera, what separates legendary Keys guides from everyone else is attitude and consistency more than pure fish-finding ability. Maintaining a positive approach regardless of conditions, continually learning, and providing a great experience for clients matters as much as putting them on fish.
How has Florida Keys fishing changed over the decades?
With decades of guiding experience in the Keys, Paul has witnessed significant changes in the fishery, client expectations, and how guides operate. Technology has transformed fish-finding and navigation, while the culture and demands of the profession have evolved considerably over his career.
What sports did Paul Tejera play before becoming a fishing guide?
Paul Tejera played college baseball before becoming highly ranked in Florida tennis in his 20s. The mental disciplines and physical training from these sports directly transferred to his success as a fishing guide and his ability to return to competitive tennis decades later at age 63.
Related Episodes
More conversations with legendary Keys guides who've shaped the sport over decades
Insights on building a sustainable guiding career from professionals who've done it successfully
How elite anglers and guides maintain focus and positivity through challenging conditions
How lessons from competitive sports transfer to fishing and other outdoor pursuits
Sponsors
The marine care products trusted by professional guides like Paul and Tom to keep their boats performing in harsh saltwater conditions. From cleaners to polishes to engine treatments, Star brite delivers the quality that matters on the water.
Shop Star britePremium trolling motor anchors and accessories designed for serious anglers who demand reliability and performance. Built to handle the toughest conditions and keep you positioned exactly where you need to be.
Check Out DancoThe nutrition and supplements that fuel peak performance whether you're on the water, in the gym, or competing on the tennis court. Quality ingredients for serious athletes and outdoor enthusiasts.
Shop 1st PhormPerformance nutrition designed for hunters and outdoor athletes who push their limits. Clean energy and recovery products for those who demand more from themselves and their gear.
Visit MTN OPSBuilt-to-last gear for people who train hard and live harder. From rucksacks to training equipment, GORUCK delivers military-grade quality for civilians who refuse to settle.
Shop GORUCKCapt. Paul Tejera - Florida Keys fishing guide, real estate investor, competitive tennis player
Download the Tom Rowland Podcast Knot Guide to master the essential knots every angler needs to know.
Capt. Paul Tejera
Capt. Paul Tejera is a legendary fishing guide based in the Florida Keys with decades of experience on the water. A former college baseball player, Paul became highly ranked in Florida tennis in his 20s before setting the sport aside for thirty years to pursue guiding, real estate, kiteboarding, and other outdoor pursuits. At 63, he returned to the court and quickly climbed to second-ranked in the state in the 18-and-over 4.0 division, still competing against players in their 30s. His perpetually positive attitude and consistent performance have made him one of the most sought-after guides in the Keys. Connect with Paul on Instagram via DM.
Listen or watch on your favorite platform:
About this Guest