Tom Rowland Podcast Episode 1016 is a conversation with veteran South Fork of the Snake River fishing guide Ed Emory, who walks through how a first-time client landed a 30.5-inch brown trout, a fish that cleared Idaho's 30-inch catch-and-release state-record mark, after his own 36 seasons and 67,000 guided river miles. Ed breaks down the landing, his prize-fighter philosophy for fighting trophy trout, where the river's biggest fish actually live, and the conservation fight over what should swim in the South Fork.
Listen now: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · Press play in the player above to watch.
Ed Emory is a fishing guide on the South Fork of the Snake River in Idaho who guides out of South Fork Lodge. He has guided for 36 seasons and logged about 67,000 guided river miles, which he points out is roughly 2.8 times the circumference of the globe with clients in his boat. He is known for targeting and landing exceptionally large brown trout and for an analytical, psychology-driven approach to guiding and fighting big fish.
The fish measured 30.5 inches, with a girth Ed describes as about as big around as his thigh and a pectoral fin large enough to cover his client's entire hand. It is the largest brown trout he has landed on the South Fork since his 31.2-inch brown in 2011, and it cleared the 30-inch mark that Idaho recognizes for a catch-and-release state record. The fish was caught, measured, photographed, and released on film.
A client named Caroline Langdale, whom Ed describes as a petite angler from Georgia, on her first-ever day fishing the South Fork. She turkey hunts and had caught saltwater fish such as tarpon and redfish before, and Ed credits that saltwater experience for how she fought and landed the fish, keeping the rod bent at the right angle and sliding the fish sideways into the net rather than trying to lift it.
Ed treats it like a prize fight. He throws a jab to test what the fish will do, reads its response, and refuses to accelerate the fight, letting the fish tire itself rather than forcing it. He stresses situational awareness, knowing the river bottom, the hazards, and the depth where the fish lives, and keeping big fish in the 10-to-15-foot water they are comfortable in rather than dragging them into deep holes. He says landing big fish is mostly between the ears.
Ed's theory is that the population of smaller guardian fish is near a historic low, so a fly reaches the largest trout instead of being intercepted by the many smaller fish that would normally feed first. With fewer fish between the angler and the big ones, anglers are gaining access to trophy browns that usually sit concealed at depth, feeding on the easy food that drifts to them.
Idaho Fish and Game has worked to remove rainbow and hybrid trout, including by electroshocking, which was halted when funding ran out, to favor cutthroat. Ed argues the river is no longer a native cutthroat fishery but a wild, naturally reproducing one, since hatchery Snake River fine-spotted cutthroat have passed through the dam from Palisades Reservoir for decades. He favors cutthroat-centric management, such as placing egg boxes with Snake River fine-spotted cutthroat eggs in the river, and letting anglers decide what they keep.
Tom Rowland Podcast Episode 1016 with Ed Emory is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, and iHeartRadio. The video version is embedded at the top of this page.
I have fished the South Fork with Ed as a client, and I brought my son Turner's bachelor party to his boat, so when a photo of a 30.5-inch brown trout came across my phone at my mother-in-law's birthday party, I knew exactly what it meant. Every angler wants that fish. Every guide wants it more. Ed has spent 36 seasons and 67,000 river miles earning the right to put a client on a fish like that, and I wanted to hear the whole thing from the guide's seat, the decisions, the doubts, the river knowledge most people never see. Press play in the YouTube player at the top of this page.
Caroline had never fished the South Fork before that day. It was cold, raining, snowing down to 8,000 feet, and she had already lost two good fish to the current before the big one ate. What happened next came down to a rod angle, a submerged tree, a death roll, and a long-handled net, plus a couple of decisions Ed made in seconds that most anglers would have gotten wrong. He walks through every move of that fight in the episode. Listen to that stretch in the player above.
The rig that fooled the 30.5-inch brown was not fresh out of the box. The day before, those same two flies were broken off by a different angler on a different fish, drifted a mile downstream, and were recovered in a way Ed says he has seen only a handful of times in 25 seasons. He kept them for a reason. When Caroline lost a big fish near a tree, Ed reached for those exact flies and tied them on knowing what they had already been through. Hear how that played out in the episode.
Ed does not muscle big fish, and he does not let his clients muscle them either. He describes the fight as a prize fight, a jab to test the fish, a read on what it does next, then a counter, never accelerating the battle and never trying to beat the fish by force. He also has strong opinions about how much to coach a client mid-fight, and when saying less lands more fish than saying more. He lays out the whole philosophy in the player above.
Ed calls the biggest browns megalodons, and he has a theory about where they hold and why so few anglers ever touch one. Neither of his two giant fish had a single human-caused hook scar, which tells him they live concealed at a depth most people never fish, picking up easy food the way big bluefish feed under a school of smaller fish. He connects that to why this particular season has produced so many large fish. The full explanation is worth hearing in his own words in the episode.
This is the part that goes beyond one big fish. Ed has tangled with Idaho Fish and Game over how the South Fork should be managed, electroshocking, rainbow and hybrid removal, and what counts as a native cutthroat after decades of hatchery fish passing through the dam. He makes a detailed, pointed case for managing the river around wild, naturally reproducing cutthroat, and he does not pull punches about the agency's motives. Listen to that section of the episode for the full argument.
Listen to the full conversation: Apple Podcasts · Spotify · or watch in the YouTube player at the top of this page.
What stays with me a day after this conversation is not the size of the fish, even though it is the biggest brown I have ever seen come out of the South Fork. It is the craft. Near the end of our conversation I told Ed exactly how I see him, and I meant every word of it:
There are certain people that take guiding to an art form and they work on it every single day, and you, my friend, are one of these people.
That is the read on the client, the read on the river, and the patience to let a fish beat itself. The trophy is the headline. The attention underneath it, built over 36 seasons, is the part I want listeners to hear, along with the fight he is willing to have to protect the river those fish come from.
Press play in the player above, or grab Episode 1016 on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
South Fork Lodge · South Fork of the Snake River · Caroline Langdale · Oliver White · Idaho Fish and Game · Palisades Reservoir · Jackson Hole / Flat Creek Fish Hatchery · University of Wyoming · Grand Targhee · Douglas Sky G · Snake River fine-spotted cutthroat · Yellowstone cutthroat · Snake River Animal Shelter
Ed Emory is a veteran fly-fishing guide on the South Fork of the Snake River in Idaho who has guided for 36 seasons and logged roughly 67,000 guided river miles out of South Fork Lodge. He specializes in large brown trout and naturally reproducing cutthroat, and has landed two of the biggest browns in the river's modern history, a 31.2-incher in 2011 and a 30.5-incher this season. He is an advocate for cutthroat-centric management of the fishery, books almost a year out, and can be reached through South Fork Lodge or his Ed Emory page on Facebook.
Subscribe to get the latest episodes, show notes, and exclusive content delivered straight to your inbox.