Mark Weeks: Poontown, Tarpon Tournaments and Quitting Law to Win One

Listen to this Episode

This episode is brought to you by Star brite — Premium marine cleaning and maintenance for your boat.

Episode Show Notes

Mark Weeks is a novelist and former international lawyer who spent more than 700 days chasing tarpon on fly in the Florida Keys. Yesterday he sat down with me for Episode 1036 of the Tom Rowland Podcast, a conversation about his novel Poontown, why he left his law practice at 56 to try to win one of the big invitational tarpon tournaments, and what it actually felt like when he and his guide, Andy Thompson, finally did it.

Watch or listen now: YouTube · Audio episode. You can also press play in the video player above.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Poontown by Mark Weeks about?

Poontown is a novel about tarpon fly fishing and the obsession that comes with it. It follows five angler and guide teams over five days as they compete for the Sabalo Cup, a fictional tournament that sits at the top of a pyramid of elite events, so a team has to win one of the other big tournaments before it can be invited. The story opens fifty years in the future, when an old angler finds a dusty Sabalo Cup trophy in a small fishing museum, and then goes back to the season the tournament still ran.

Is Poontown a true story?

No. The disclaimer in the book says only the fish are real. Mark takes a kernel from real experiences on the water and stories he heard on the skiff, then builds fiction around it. He moved the setting out of the Keys and the Everglades into an invented place inspired by them, because he felt the Keys have such a strong personality that they would compete with the story he wanted to tell about the fish and the people who chase them.

Why is Poontown modeled on Neverland and Peter Pan?

Mark read Bob Rich's description of Andy Mill as Peter Pan and thought it fit tarpon season perfectly. During the season, everyone is a lost boy chasing the same thing, the days melt together, and nobody cares what is happening in the rest of the world. He went back and read the 1910 version of Peter Pan and found so many lines that matched life in the Keys that he used them as the epigraph for each chapter.

How do you get invited to a major invitational tarpon tournament?

Mark chaired the Don Hawley Tarpon Tournament for two years, and he says the waiting lists for the major events are long. The committee looks for the teams most likely to compete hard, because the tournament's proceeds support the Guides Trust Foundation and the event needs serious anglers to keep going. It helps to have won another tournament, to have guides and other anglers vouch for your skills, and to be known as trustworthy, because the sport relies on the honesty of the people in it. Committees also look closely at who the guide is.

How physical is tarpon tournament fishing for the angler?

Mark says it is far more physical than most people expect. He started competing at 56 and changed how he treated his body completely, going to the gym every day in the off-season, watching his diet, skipping alcohol during the season and getting at least seven hours of sleep. Anglers stand on the bow from early morning into the afternoon with nothing to lean on, eat on the run and have to stay sharp enough to react the moment a fish shows up, often for five tournament days in a row.

Why does the guide matter so much in tarpon tournaments?

Mark believes the guide is the most important tool in the angler's toolbox. In his view, an excellent guide can lead a mediocre angler to a win far more often than the other way around, and he knows of only one rare case where a top angler essentially guided an out-of-town guide to victory. That is why tournament committees often ask who the guide is before they look at the angler.

Why I Wanted Mark On the Show

I have fished the Gold Cup and the Hawley, and I spent twenty years guiding, so I know how strange and how all-consuming that world is. I have always felt like someone needed to write about it, and when I read Poontown I thought Mark got a lot of it right. He came into it the hard way, as an angler who decided late in his career that he wanted to win, and then went and did it. I wanted to hear how a lawyer with an international practice ends up on the bow for three months a year, and how he turned all of it into a novel.

What Happens When a Lawyer Offers His Guide Five Years?

Mark had been fishing with Andy Thompson for years when he made him an offer: three months a year in the Keys for five years, with the goal of winning one of the big tournaments before he turned 60. He had not been invited to a single tournament yet. When he laid it all out, Andy just listened and did not react at all. I know from the guide's side how much that kind of commitment means, because the guide is giving up those 90 days too. Mark has a theory about why Andy said yes, and it is worth hearing him tell it.

What Does a Tournament Guide Teach You That a Fishing Guide Doesn't?

I think there is a real difference between a great tarpon angler and a tournament tarpon angler, and Mark lived that difference. Once they committed, everything got micromanaged, down to the weight in the boat and the cooler Andy packed. A lot of it was mindset: how to let go of a fish that just changed the tournament, how not to get too excited, and why the calmer you are, the better you fish. Mark also learned to stay in his own boat and never second-guess his guide. There is a story about a giant fish, a bucket and what Andy told him next that you need to hear.

Hear the whole conversation: scroll back up and press play in the YouTube player, or listen to the full episode here.

Why Do People Tell Their Guide Things They Wouldn't Tell a Therapist?

One line in Poontown made me laugh because it is true. People on a skiff say things they would never say anywhere else, and I heard a lot of it over the years. Mark has a thoughtful answer for why that happens, and it has to do with what you see on the way out to the fish and what you leave behind on the dock. We also talked about how somebody who gives advice for a living handles being told what to do all day, and how he learned to listen. His answer to that one is humble and funny.

Should Anglers Who Can't Win Give Up Their Tournament Spots?

Mark knows this is a controversial view, and he says it anyway. In the major tarpon tournaments, once you are invited you tend to keep getting invited, and there are younger anglers waiting for a spot. He has a specific rule in mind, and it ties straight back to Peter Pan and what happens to lost boys who grow up. Whether you agree or not, I think it is a conversation the tournament world needs to have, and Mark explains it better than I can here.

How Do 700 Days of Fishing Notes Turn Into a Novel?

Mark wrote notes after every single day on the water, starting when he only had two days a year in the Keys and did not want to start from zero the next spring. He never planned to write a book from them. Those notes, and all the characters he met along the way, became Poontown. He describes himself as a writer who starts without knowing the ending, except for the five tournament days, which he had to map out. He also shared a simple ten-minute trick that once kept him writing until two in the morning, and I think it works for a lot more than writing.

What Does It Feel Like to Finally Win the Big One?

Mark fished a lot more tournaments than he won. When he and Andy finally won, he says he did not feel the way he thought he would. He compares it to the last line of a novel he loves, and the feeling he describes surprised me. We also talked about why he decided to hang up his rod, what Andy said when he heard, and what comes next for him as a writer. I am not going to give that part away.

Final Thoughts From Me

Yesterday's conversation with Mark brought back a lot of memories from my own years on the poling platform. He understands the guide-angler relationship as well as anyone I have talked to, and he respects the guides in a way that shows up all over his book.

If you have ever fished for tarpon, you will recognize the people in this conversation. If you never have, I think you will understand why some very successful people give up so much to chase a fish that pays nobody.

Press play: watch in the YouTube player at the top of this page, or listen to the audio episode.

People & Brands Mentioned

Mark Weeks · Andy Thompson · Andy Mill · Nicky Mill · Brian Esposito · Scott Collins · Paul Dickson · Randy Towle · Eizo Morihashi · Bob Rich · Stu Apte · Tim O'Brien · Baker Bishop · Alan Finkelman · Mike Criscola · Monte Burke · Ted Williams · Stephen King · Thomas McGuane · Don Hawley Tarpon Tournament · Gold Cup · Golden Fly · Tarpon Cup · Guides Trust Foundation · Poontown

About Mark Weeks

Mark Weeks is a novelist and former international lawyer who speaks Japanese and has worked with Japan since 1978, including years in his firm's Tokyo office. He started fly fishing for tarpon in the Florida Keys in 2001, began competing in the invitational tarpon tournaments at 56, chaired the Don Hawley Tarpon Tournament for two years and won a major tournament with guide Andy Thompson. He has also caught fly-rod world records. Poontown is his second novel. His first is a technology legal thriller set largely in Japan, and he is writing its sequel.

Star brite
Premium marine cleaning and maintenance for your boat.
Shop Star brite
Free Knot Guide
Tom's free fishing knot guide for inshore and offshore.
Download Knot Guide
Broadwater Boatworks
Purpose-Precision-Performance - See why Tom loves the 25 Bay Cat. Yep, a catamaran Bay Boat...Game Changer
Explore Broadwater Boats
Cayo Boat Works
With Cayo Boatworks, you're not just investing in a skiff; you're embracing a legacy of innovation and craftsmanship that redefines the boundaries of shallow water fishing.
Explore Cayo Boats
Aquaphobix
Thermopolymer Foul Release Coating for Boat Hulls - Environmentally Safe bottom paint alternative
Explore Aquaphobix
GORUCK
Black Friday pricing: Rucking Weight Vest $89 (was $155), plus a free Basic Rucker on $300+ orders. No code needed.
Shop The Weight Vest
MTN OPS
Nutrition for outdoor athletes. Use code TOMFREESHIP for free shipping.
Shop MTN OPS
1st Phorm
Premium supplements to fuel your body. Free shipping on every order.
Shop 1st Phorm
Nuvio Recovery
Red light therapy recovery mat. Use code TOM50 for $50 off.
Shop Nuvio Recovery

Episode Transcript

Transcript

Tom Rowland Podcast — Episode 1036: Mark Weeks

In this episode: Mark Weeks on his tarpon novel Poontown, why he modeled it on Neverland, leaving his law practice at 56 to chase the invitational tarpon tournaments with guide Andy Thompson, the tournament mindset, the guide-angler relationship, turning 700 days of fishing notes into a novel, and what winning actually felt like.

0:00 · Cold Open: Why Poontown Is Fiction

Hi, I'm Mark Weeks, and I'm the author of Poontown, and this is The Tom Rowland Podcast. Mark, it's nice to meet you. I'm glad we could- Likewise ... get this set up. Yeah, it's a honor and a pleasure to be here. Thanks. Um, and same for you. This- I think it's, it's more than past time for someone to write an article about this crazy world of tarpon tournaments, and that's, that's what you've done with Poontown.

I was thinking that it was going to be, like, a real story, but then the way that you set it up, it was fictional, I guess. Yeah, that's right. Um, I, uh, I- that was intentional, and in fact, I took it out of the Keys and the Everglades and put it in a fictional place inspired by the Keys and the Everglades. And, um, I decided to, uh, make it fictional because I wanted the focus to be on the fish, the tarpon, and the obsession and the feeling that, uh, fly fishing for tarpon engenders in people and, and why it makes people do the things they do, including, in some cases, as you know, uh, quitting their day jobs and moving to the Keys and, and sometimes ends up in divorces and just people do irrational things because, um, it's really an addiction, just like being on drugs and they're, uh, you know, ch- forever chasing the, the dragon of that first, uh, jumped tarpon, uh, you know, when they first saw a 100-pound fish leave the- that turquoise, um, water there in the Keys.

Yeah. So the disclaimer on your book says, "Only the fish are real." Yeah, that's right. So how true is that? Yeah, that, that's, that's absolutely right. Um, with, with characters and with stories, you get a, a kernel of each from, uh, experiences you have with people and also experiences you have on the water. And then stories you hear on the water, as you know- Mm-hmm

uh, people will tell you things on a skiff that they wouldn't tell their therapist. Um, and, but, uh, then I take that kernel, and I, I build around that in my fiction. And you also chose, um, Neverland and Peter Pan. Yeah. So, um, there's a long story behind that. Um, it, it's, it's sort of also what inspired me to write the novel.

2:00 · Neverland, Peter Pan and the Lost Boys

Um, I read, uh, Bob Rich's fi- uh, book, um, Catching Big Fish, um, which I think has been republished. Or no, no, not Catching Big Fish. I'm sorry. Fish, Fish Bites. Fish- Fishing Club. Yeah. Oh, Fishing Club. And in that book, he, he referred to, uh, um, uh, Millstone, um, Andy Mill as, uh, Peter Pan, and I thought that was really perfect because when you are in the Keys during tarpon season, it is a lot like Neverland in the sense that we're all lost boys there for the same thing.

All we talk about is the weather, the fish, the other anglers, the guides, our significant others, and one day just melds into the next, as you know, uh, better than most. Um, you don't even know what date it is. Maybe you know what the day is, uh, because you have to know who, what guide or what angler you're gonna be fishing with.

Um, and then, um, uh, uh, Andy was referred to as Peter Pan in another book that I'm, I'm blanking on, but I just thought that that analogy was so perfect, um, that, that I decided to, um, model the imaginary place on Neverland and also the feelings that, that people have when they're there. Mm-hmm. Um, and, and I read, I actually read the 1910 version of Peter Pan, and there were so many comments in there, um, that really reflected what's going on in the Keys when you're tarpon fishing that I decided to use, um, those comments as an epigraph at the beginning of each chapter.

4:00 · Aging Out of Tournament Fishing

Who in the book do you think never grows up? Oh, uh, it's a, a really good question. Um, I, I think that, um, um, certainly the main character was struggling with that. And also there's another character, um, Sonya, um, was, was certainly struggling with that bef- uh, and I don't wanna, um, give away the story, but, you know, there comes a time when, um, uh, in all events, I remember Stu Apte in his book talked about aging out of being a pilot, for example.

Mm-hmm. Um, and there comes a time where you age out of, uh, tournament fishing, for example. At least if you're, you're honest with yourself, I think there comes a time where you realize you're not gonna win. You know, there's not a path to winning. And, uh, I know s- a lot of pe- not a lot of people, but some people hang on because they enjoy the social aspect of it, or they are hoping someday lightning might strike.

Um, but, uh, uh, that's, that's what, um, different anglers, particularly, um, two of them are struggling with as they, you know, they're getting, it's getting later in life. And so, hey, the interesting thing about that question is there's, there's actually a quote in Peter Pan where Peter Pan ta- or the narrator talks about how, uh, lost boys age out, and Peter Pan basically, uh, makes them leave the island or he kills them.

It's really kind of, uh, brutal. And, uh, there's definitely some of that going on. I see it in the tournament circuit. Um, and I've seen, you know, grand champions, uh, struggle with that. I, I think that that's sort of universal across, um, different competitive endeavors. Is that a sad thing to watch somebody age out of it and, and not choose to- Like bow out and, and they just keep hanging on?

6:00 · Should Anglers Who Can't Win Give Up Their Spots?

Well, uh, this is gonna be controversial, but my view is in all the tur- major tarpon tournaments, there are long waiting lists. And, uh, typically when, once you get invited, you will continue to be invited each year, uh, uh, un- until you quit, unless, you know, you do something, uh, you cheat or something like that.

Um, and my view is because there are younger people and perhaps better people in the wings, that if you realize it's not going to happen, that you should bow out and open that spot up for somebody on the waiting list. That's my personal view, and I have voiced this before, that maybe we should have a rule that if you're not in the top, you know, um, 10, um- Hmm

for a certain number of, let's say four years in a row, that you should, um, have to quit. Uh, or that... But that's my view and that, and I realize that's a controversial view and, and, you know, they, they are so competitive, much more competitive than they were, say, in the '90s in terms of just getting invited, um, with long waiting lists.

I just don't think it's fair to the people on the waiting list. A lot of other sports do that. You know, if you... I mean, in the UFC, if you lose three, three fights in a row, they won't renew your contract. Like there, there are certain performance things that could be pulled from other- Other sports, I think, the top 10, if you don't make top 10 in the, in the last four years, that seems, that seems reasonable.

7:00 · How to Get Off the Waiting List

You know, but a lot of people, a lot of people do wanna get in these tournaments, and the... How, how competitive is the, the waiting list? Is there a way to get in to these t- Yeah, there's a way to get in. Um, definitely. I mean, uh, I was chair of the Hawley, the Don Hawley, uh, Tarpon Tournament for two years, and there's a long waiting list there.

And the focus of, uh, um, the, the tournament when looking at that, uh, list is who's going to be the most competitive. Um, because we want the tournament to continue. You know, in the case of the Hawley, for example, the proceeds go to support the Guides Trust Foundation, which, uh, supports, um, guides in need and also conservation- Mm-hmm

i- in the Keys and Everglades. So obviously we want it to continue, um, to support the, those purposes. And the one way to do that is to make sure that, uh, the people who are competing in it, uh, are excited about winning, and that it's not just a bunch of guys getting together for, for fun. Uh, so yeah, you can definitely get in, but you have to show your bona fides, and it helps to have won another tournament.

It helps to have guides and other anglers say good things about your, um, your, your angling skills. And also there's some vetting as to what kind of a person you are because obviously we want, um, trustworthy people competing in the tournament since it's a gentleman's sport, right? It's, it's really relying on the trustworthiness of the, the anglers, uh, when it, when it comes to making sure people aren't cheating, for example.

9:00 · Why the Guide Matters Most

When you're vetting, um, someone for that wedding, waiting list, do you take into account just the angler or also the guide-angler team? Well, that's an excellent question, and the answer is usually we look at the guide too. So one of the first questions is: Who is the guide? I mean, it... my, my personal view is, and I think Andy Mill and others would agree, that, uh, the most important, um, tool in the angler's toolbox, so to speak, is in fact the guide.

In other words, he's the, he is the, he's the critical person in that two-person, uh, team. I think a, you know, 90% of the time or 99% of the time, uh, an excellent guide can, uh, lead a mediocre angler to winning. Um, the other way around happens far, far less. I, I know of, of one example where basically a, an excellent angler Uh, I heard picked up a guide from Texas who really didn't know the waters and guided the guide and, and, and won at least one of the tournaments, but that is exceedingly rare.

10:00 · How Physical Tournaments Are for the Angler

Yeah. How, how physi- I mean, I know that these... I, I fished the Gold Cup and the Hawley, and I know how physical it is for the guide. It's extremely physical. How physical are these tournaments for the angler? Well, um, I can only speak to myself, uh, a- as a sedentary lawyer who- ... um, started competing when I was 56.

Um, I really felt like I had to ch- I had to change how I treated my body, and I really had to, uh, treat it as a sport and start going to the gym every day and watching my diet. And I, I never drank during the season, alcohol during the season, for example. Um, in the off-season, I, like I said, was in the gym every day.

Um, y- during the season, I made sure to get at least seven hours of sleep. That's something that Brian Esposito told me early on, is you gotta get at least seven when you're fishing that many days. Um, and the, the reason you wanna be as fit as you can is because you're standing up on that bow all day, and you wanna be able to take adva- take advantage of any opportunity that comes along.

So if you start feeling sleepy or tired, your reaction times are slower. And, um, you know, I, I did have one guide, Andy Thompson, say to me that, um, it can be really tough to be an angler because you don't have a pole to lean on- Mm-hmm ... when you're standing out there. Mm-hmm. And, and during the day, you know, you s- as you know, you start fishing at 6:00 and you're, you're going all day until 3:00.

Um, you can't be sitting down and resting, right? No. Uh, and you've gotta eat on the run and, I mean, it's just go, go, go, go, go. And so if you're having a few drinks at night, and I've, I've talked to other anglers about this, people who are much younger than I am, you know, in their 40s or 30s, and they say the same thing, you know, your butt's dragging the next morning.

So you, you have to treat it like a, like the sport that it is, and I've noticed that the really excellent guys treat it that way. Um, and I mean, they're, they're approaching it as a professional sport. Yeah. Yeah, well that's, that's, I think that's, that's the only way. I mean, I, I... It's a five-day tournament and that's, that's a lot of time.

13:00 · Andy Mill's Work Ethic

It's a really, a lot of time. Very, very physical. There's a reason- So in your- You know it- Go ahead. Sorry. Go ahead. No, no. There's a reason why I was just gonna say, there's a reason that somebody like Andy Mill, a professional athlete, was able to win the Gold Cup five times, right? Mm-hmm. Um, I mean, he's, he's got that discipline.

Also, you know, uh, just the hand-eye coordination and the other skills necessary to be a top flight athlete. There's, there's a reason that he did so well when others who pr- may have fished much more, uh, didn't. And, uh, and I fished with Andy a few times, and I'll tell you, the, the work ethic that I experienced was just ex- both, both when he was fishing and on the poling platform, was just extraordinary.

And the level of energy, the high level of energy that he was able to maintain all day, every day, uh, was really kind of mind-blowing. In fact, his son, I s- I, I had, I had the pleasure of fishing with his son Nicky once, and he was telling me how, um, when he was growing up, that they'd go down to the Keys and start fishing before light.

They'd throw plugs in the channel. Then when the sun came up, they'd go out in the flats and fish and, and eat lunch, and they, they took dinner with them, too. And then when it got dark, they went and threw plugs in the channel again, got back, went to bed at 10:00 and got up the next morning and did it all over again.

And he thought that that was normal, that everybody did that. Um- Dark to dark ... and, yeah, dark to dark. And as you know, almost nobody's doing that. Yeah. I mean, it's, it's hard to do that for many days in a row. Yeah, exactly. I mean, very, very difficult, and you do have to take care of your body. In your book, um, you talk about Greg, the character, that he's a lawyer.

15:00 · Greg, the Lawyer Who Sells His Practice

He sells his practice to go chase the Gold Cup. And is- Yeah ... is that you? So Greg is, is the one character who probably the most resembles a real person, and I would say he's the closest to me. And, um, uh, you know, they say write what you know, so, um, he was the, the first character that I started with, and then I built around him.

I didn't know what other characters there were going to be, but I knew I wanted it to be a diverse cast. As you know, there are 25 teams in most of these tournaments. Mm-hmm. Um, but I knew that would be way too complicated and, and unnecessary. So the way I set it up is, uh, the Sabalo Cup is the premier tournament.

It's like a pyramid, you know. To get into that you have to win one of the other elite tournaments, and then you have to get invited to the Sabalo Cup, and then it's just five teams- Mm ... uh, competing. And I did it that way so I could follow each of those teams. Yeah. And for you personally- You decide this at, at 56 years old that you're going to, uh, well, maybe you can tell me exactly how it went, but how did your decision go to, um, leave the firm and chase this tarpon dream that you had?

16:00 · The First Tarpon and the Push to Compete

So I started fishing in 2001, um, for a couple days in the Keys and, and, uh, and I jumped one, um, off of Matecumbe Beach, and that just changed my life. Um, and then, you know, the next year I went for three days and, and over time, you know, five days. And then I, I actually was working in our Tokyo office, um, after 2004 when I moved from our New York office, and there was a window in, uh, late April and early May when I could go for two weeks, and so every year I went for two weeks.

And I would talk to different people, you know, about the tournaments. Um, I met Andy Mill. I met Eizo Morihashi. You probably have heard that name- Mm-hmm. Sure ... in Japan. I fished with him in Japan a fair amount, fished with him in Mongolia, um, and, um, also, um, in Malaysia. We fished together in the Keys, and he told me about his tournament experience, and I was intrigued, and Andy Mill told me about his experience, and I was intrigued.

And when I'd be fishing with, uh, with Eizo in, um, in Japan, I'd talk about, "Oh, I'd like to do it. You know, it's interesting." And there was a, there's a tournament in Japan that he runs, and I fished in that tournament and, and, uh, and it's a, a s- sea bass, what they call a sea bass or Suzuki tournament. Um, and w- at one point in time, he said, "Well, you better do it soon or you're gonna do, be too old."

And, and that was like a, you know, splash of cold water on the face. And, and I was fishing with Andy Thompson a lot at the time, but Andy had a young angler that he was very... They were fishing the tournaments together, and he was very excited. Um, the guy was good and, um, and, and he thought, and he was, he was, you know, r- really motivated, and he had the time and money to, to spend a lot of time focusing on it.

And, uh, so I thought, "Well, there's no way I'm gonna get Andy Thompson to, to fish me." And then that guy got married and had children, and I guess his wife put his, her foot down, and, um, so he dropped out. He dropped out of the Gold Cup or something first, and then the other two, the Golden Fly and the Hawley later on.

18:00 · Offering Andy Thompson Five Years

And, and Andy Thompson was telling me this, and I jumped in, I said, "I'll tell you what." Uh, if you'll fish me, I'll give you five years, and I'll spend three months a year down here practicing." Wow. And, and, uh, 'cause, 'cause I, I knew I'd have... I said, "Let's try to win one by the time I turn 60." And, um, my son was already grown and, and so I thought it was the, the best time for me.

I think I was 54 at the time. And then we planned, and then... But I hadn't been invited to any of the tournaments yet, but I just on faith thought, "Well, if I go down there and show up, you know, I'll eventually get invited," which is what happened. Well, that kind of- Now, there was some- ... also goes back to the, when, when you have a guide like Andy Thompson, your chances of getting in are probably far greater because they know- Yeah

"Okay, well, this is a great guide." Yeah. Good chance of getting picked. Plus he knows people and, and, uh, he knew people who introduced me to people. I mean, like Tim O'Brien said, "Well, if you wanna get in the Gold Cup and the Golden Fly, you really need to talk to this guy." And, um, and that was hugely helpful advice and, and, uh, I got into the, um, the Tarpon Cup, which was the easiest to get into first, and then, um, Baker Bishop, who was then chair of the, the Hawley, was kind enough to invite me to the Hawley, and then eventually I got into the Gold Cup and the Golden Fly.

And I really wanted to fish... By this time I was already working on the book, and I really wanted to fish the Gold Cup because I knew that was, you know, the Olympics. Um, it's all the Olympics, but the Gold Cup is really special as the oldest, you know, and most prestigious. I mean, it was, you know, started by Ted Williams and...

So, um, eventually, yeah, I got in. Um, but I think just showing up and fishing a lot and meeting different people had something to do with it. So when you decide that you're, you're going to make this commitment to Andy and you're going to make this commitment, you're leaving the firm, what did, what did it feel like on the last day of the firm for you?

20:00 · Leaving the Firm

Well, I, I really was blessed to, to, um- To be working at a great firm. Um, I have a long history with Japan going back to 1978. I speak Japanese. Uh, my son still lives there. I love Japan and, uh, I had a great practice, and the practice was fun. It was a global international practice. And so it was, um ... But I'd been doing it for, you know, decades, and, um, so but it, a- and I just realized, look, if I don't do this now, I'm never gonna do it.

I can always go back to practicing law if I want to. Um, but I felt, it felt sort of liberating to realize financially that I could actually do this, you know, after all this, these years of work. Um, and I got my finances in order and I realized, okay, I can actually do this. Um, and, and that was a very liberating feeling.

21:00 · Three Months in Neverland

And then when I first showed up in the Keys in 2018 for that first three-month stretch, which actually turned into four, um- That whole thing was just completely liberating. I mean, every day, you know, you're on the water, it's the same routine, and like I say, you're all talking about the same things. And the guides knew I was serious 'cause I was there when they were there, you know, no days off except for weather kind of thing.

And so we really developed close relationships, and I saw how hard they worked, you know, and they were always there on time, and nobody's hungover, and, and we're all talking about, well, how can we be, you know, as good as possible at this game? And it was just such a wonderful feeling 'cause it was just complete immersion, right?

I was totally away from practicing law and, um, and totally away from anything else in the world, right? That's why, why you get this feeling of being in Neverland, because it's so disconnected from everywhere else, and it doesn't matter what's going on in the world, right? Um, nobody cares. All you care about is what are the fish doing, what's the moon phase, what are the tides, what's the weather, you know, who caught what when, um, should we go to the ocean, should we go to the bay, should we go to the back, should we fish the West Coast, you know.

Um, those were the only questions we were asking, right? And y- and then- Mm-hmm ... you know, as it gets later in the season, May, June, you're meeting with guides every day, and they're all bleary-eyed, and you're bleary-eyed, and then you, you, you hook some beast out there, right, some giant farm animal as, as Arno Mate as-

a South African guide said. Um, and you're just all- you're both ecstatic, right? It, it, it... You've been doing it for months, guides have been doing it for years, and it's like, like I've fished with Scott Collins, Andy too, and I've... Andy, they've been doing it for decades, right? And you'll hook some monster, and they'll both go berserk.

Yeah. Right? And it's the same th- "Oh, this is so fucking cool, man." Oh, I'm sorry, can I curse on this show? Yeah. Um, and, and that's just fabulous, right? Yeah. At least to me. No, it's, it's really amazing. And the, the relationship, one of the things that I liked so much about your book was that you, you key in on the relationship between the guide and the angler, and that is such a crucial part of not just the tarpon tournaments, but all the tournaments, and even just being a good guide on a daily basis is this relationship that, that you have with the angler and the angler has with the guide.

24:00 · What People Tell Their Guide

And one of the things that you say in there is, and, and is that people tell their guide things on the skiff that they wouldn't tell a therapist. Why do you think that is? I think they let their guard down. You know, it's like you're, it's just sometimes there'll be two anglers and a guide on the boat and, and people, you know, you're in this crucible in the, in the, uh, day-to-day world with your family and work and all the pressures there, and then you're out there on that boat in the Everglades.

You just, you saw saltwater crocodiles on the, you know, uh, on the, at the launchpad, and you drove through the Buttonwood Canal and saw all these birds take out. You get out there, you saw dolphins, you, you know, manatees, a hammerhead shark came by or... And, and, you know, you're on safari, really. It's like, uh, my brother said to me once, when you're out there and you don't really think about how special it is 'cause you're so focused on catching fish.

But all of that just, I think, you, you s- you can't, you can't look at your cellphone, it's not working, and all that just contributes to this sense of security that I think causes people to let their g- guard down and, and say stuff that, like I say, they, they're certainly not telling their wives Yeah ... put it that way.

I mean, it's also interesting to where, where you have someone like yourself who's giving advice for a living, and you are a position of authority, and then you get on a boat, and you are not the position of authority, and you are, you are taking advice from someone else. How, how did you do with that? Well, it's, it's very interesting.

I think there's a lot of people, uh, you know, anglers down there who nobody in their world talks to them like their guide does. Yes, exactly. Right? And, uh, and yet they'll just sit there and take it and then laugh about it later. And I think that the, the people, the, the anglers who, who, who do listen to their guides and do just sort of laugh it off, first of all, they know their guide wants to catch fish almost more than they do, and so the guide's just trying to help.

And then second of all, for me, I always just felt like I was a first-year law student again. Like, I don't know what I'm doing, so somebody's gotta tell me. And, uh, and sometimes, you know, when you get tired, you need a kick in the pants- Mm ... um, to get you motivated, to get that adrenaline flowing again. Yeah.

So it's a, it's a very interesting relationship, and of course each, each guide is different, each angler is different. And, uh, as a angler, I always felt like I had to adjust to the guide, um, because he knows how to catch fish in a certain way. Yes. And if I start saying, "Well, you know, when I'm with Andy, we do it like this," I mean, they don't wanna hear that.

Or maybe, maybe they, they're waiting for the secret. N- I mean- Well, unless they're, unless you- Always, always listen ... tell them, yeah. Right. Always listen. That's right. Yeah. Um, so w- in this first part, uh, where you're, where you're going down there and you're, you're starting to, to fish more and more and, were you fishing with other people other than Andy?

27:00 · Learning From the Best Guides

Like, when you- Yes ... decided that you were gonna commit to the tournament and you were gonna try to win one? Yeah, 'cause Andy, you know, he had obviously- Mm-hmm ... has other clients and, uh, so I fished with Brian Esposito, who really ran me through my paces. Um, he was really quite helpful. Um, like I say, he gave me the advice, "Do not drink.

Get at least seven hours. You know, watch your diet." All of those, you know, great pieces of advice, very helpful with my casting, stripping. He really helped me with the two hand strip, for example. And then Scott Collins, I fished many times with Jared Raskob. Um, and uh, I'd been fishing with, with Paul Dickson for years.

I fished with, continued to fish with Paul, um, who's just wonderful and, and, uh, and Paul has a very specific way of, of doing things. I mean, these people are all just amazing guides, right? And anglers too, and I, I fished with them all where they've been on the bow, and the things that they can do- Yeah, all of it.

Mm-hmm. Just, I mean, it makes it look so effortless, you know? And, uh, and then I get back up on the g- bow and despite the fact that I've already been fishing 45 days that year, I feel like a dugan. You know, they haven't cast all season, and I'm like, "Let me pole for a little while, and you can..." You know, same way with, I fished with Raul Montoro a lot.

28:00 · Swapping Places With the Guide

I remember saying, you know, "Why don't you get up there? I'll... 'Cause I gotta learn how to pole," which I'm still bad at. Um, and they would just get up there and, and just g- you know, the ca- timing of the cast would be just reading the fish. It would all be perfect. It's like, yeah, there's no other way to do it.

So why am I trying to do it some other way, right? And that was always a great mystery, but I, I highly recommend any anglers down there, let your guide throw a few. Mm-hmm. I mean, that is just so educational. If they will. A lot- If they, if they will ... a lot won't, you know? A lot are like- Yeah ... you know, you get in a mindset of, "I'm here to guide, I'm not here to fish," and, uh, y- when you're, when you're...

At least for me, when I was locked into that, it, that's not what I was there for. Like, no, we're gonna miss the tide, we're gonna miss something else if- Right ... we screw around doing this. Yeah. I'm gonna hook a fish, and we're gonna miss this other opportunity. Something's gonna happen. Like, we're here for you, right?

And some, some won't, but then some will glad- I mean, when you fish with somebody enough, they say, "You fish," and you s- you say, "Okay, I'll, I will." Um- Yeah, I used to do it at the end of the day. Yeah. You know, sort of the tide was running out or whatever, and, and I knew we only had 30 minutes and, and every- we were all relaxed, particularly if we'd caught a few fish, you know?

Yeah. Or, or even just one. You know how it is, right? Um, that's a great day. Mm-hmm. And I would say, "Why don't you get up there and let me try to pole?" Which was always comical when I was trying to pole when there was wind. It- Even worse if there was wind and current, but, um- Yeah, at first. At first, and- Cir- circular, that's the way that you can describe most people's poling style at first.

Yeah, absolutely. And I remember Raul said to me one point in time, I'm like, "Here they come," right? And he's like, "You know you have to stop the boat, right?" Yeah. Well, you know, I think that it's, I think it's a good thing for, uh, guides and anglers to swap places, especially if you're gonna be fishing a lot, because the angler realizes, "Wow, there's way more to it than I thought back here."

Yeah. And then you get up on the bow, and it's not always as easy as you thought, and you make this perfect cast, and they don't eat it, and it's like, "Oh, that's exactly what you've been doing all day." And I think it just kind of gives, gives a different perspective that's, that's healthy in the right situation.

31:00 · The Tournament Mindset

Um, I wonder, like, when you decide that you're, you, you express this to Andy, "I'm gonna come down for three months. I'm gonna put in my time, and I, my goal is to win a tournament- Yeah ... in the next four years." Yeah. Does, do, does Andy or all of the other high-profile guides that you mentioned, do they start teaching you different things like tournament tactics versus just being a, a, a good tarpon angler?

Because there, I, I feel like there's a difference between a great tarpon angler and a tournament tarpon angler Yeah, I think that's absolutely true. Well, they start talking about the mindset. Mm-hmm. Right. And then- And what do they say about the mindset? Well, that you, you need to, and which is a great lesson for life in general, you need to move on.

Don't dwell on the past, don't dwell on the losses, which easy to say, hard to do, you know? Okay, you broke off, you know, that monster, and that would've given us, uh, you know, 1,500 points or whatever. Mm-hmm. Um, but that's gone. That's in the past. You know, you gotta focus on the now. So there was, there was a lot of that.

And, um, a lot of it was about, um, how not to get too excited, right? And, um, y- y- y- as you know, Tom, the, the, the paradox is that it's a huge rush to hook and jump a tarpon. And so you're always chasing that dragon, right, um, to get that level, that, that endorphin shot, um, and that adrenaline rush from, uh, feeding and hooking a, a tarpon.

But the irony is that the calmer you are and the less you care, the better you tend to be. And, um, and also just this mindset of never give up. Never give up. You know, it's like Andy, I was yelling at one point in time, and I think I was probably beating the bucket with my rod at one point in time, and he said, "Okay, that's enough.

Time to move on." Um, 'cause I'd missed a fish. A gi- I mean, it was like a giant waker. And you know how that is, right? I mean, there's one, and I could just change the tournament for you, you miss it, and you're just like, "Oh, my God." 'Cause you know that fish is gonna eat, right, if you get it there or if you hook it.

Um, yeah, or you know if you hook... If you, if you show the fly, it's gonna eat. And then if you hook it, you know, you can land it. But, uh, you have a good chance. And just that, so that whole mindset, it's not, you're not just, it's not just a fun day on the water. Um, I mean, I know everybody says, "Oh, let's just go out and fish," but nobody approaches it that way.

Um, when you micro- Not, not when your, not when your goal is tournament at the, at the end of the season or at the peak of the season. That's totally different. Yeah. We, we were micromanaging everything. Weight in the boat, what I could and couldn't bring on the boat. Um, you know, the food we kept in the cooler.

I remember Andy used to take out his regular I- Igloo cooler and put it in a much smaller Yeti cooler, um, to, to reduce weight. Uh, just all these little things that we would focus on, where I was stripping the line, where I was standing, um, what I was, what I would do after I hooked the fish, um, after we cleared the line.

You know, um, when it's jumping, w- when do I get off of the platform... I'm sorry, the, uh, the f- the front deck, 'cause I didn't use a casting platform. But all of those little things, you know, 'cause you, you learn so much both in the tournament fishing and in the, uh, you know, the pre-fishing- Mm-hmm ... that you just wanna manage everything to minimize anything that could go wrong, um, and reduce that as much as possible.

35:00 · Staying in Your Own Boat

And so that also plays into Um, like Andy has a way that he wants it done, and- Yeah ... it may have to do with the way that he puts the pole up, the way that he jumps off the platform, the way that he's going to manage the boat once you hook up. So you have to start, like if you're really committed to this and you're really going to, to fish with Andy in these tournaments, at some point you have to subscribe to the things that he's telling you, and not necessarily anything that you've learned from other people.

Did you feel that way? Yeah. Oh, absolutely. Absolutely, 'cause I want him to feel as comfortable and as confident as possible. And I, I remember, um, Randy Towle told me at one point in time, uh, there comes a point where your angler, uh, plateaus. No matter how much they practice, how much they fish, they're not gonna get any better than that.

So, and then at that point, the question is, how well can the angler and the guide mesh- Mm ... as a team? And so I know Andy was always trying to manage my mental state to keep it in, in the game, and I also didn't wanna say anything to him, um, that, uh, and he was super focused like all the time, but that would discourage him and, or, or, you know, I didn't want his head to get out of the zone.

And so I would not, I never said, "Well, maybe we should have gone to the ocean." You know, I, I never said, "Oh, I wonder what those guys over down there who went to, uh, you know, Key West are doing or at the Bowling Alley," wherever, right? Mm-hmm. Um, so I, I, one of the things I learned about tournament fishing is you have to stay in your own boat, which completely makes sense because you have no control over what other people are doing or what they can do.

You're not even really competing against them. You're just competing against yourself- Right ... and the, and the fish. Um, and so that was something that, that I, I had to learn. And that, you know, guides, guides don't want to hear that you're second-guessing them. Mm-hmm. Right? And so the only time I would provide input is if Andy asked me, um, which every once in a while he did, and I was kind of shocked when he would.

Um, 'cause usually he had a very clear plan, and he always had... He was always thinking two, three spots ahead. Yeah. 'Cause as you know, you know, the next spot, somebody may be there. Well, what if that doesn't pan out? For what- then he was onto something else. Um- Well, there is a, there is a situation to where as a guide, you're, you're pretty much equally confident in plan A or plan B.

They may be 100 miles apart But you're pretty confident in each, each one of those, and that's where I think a guide will ask for the perspective of the angler, which, because you want the angler, just as, just like you're saying, you want Andy to be very comfortable and you want, you want everybody to, in the boat to be confident.

So if, if, if the angler is not quite, you know, if there's any hesitation, then the, then the other one is better, right? Like, that's... You're, you're pretty confident in both. Let's go where the angler is the most confident as well so that you're both on the same page. This is what we decided to do, we're gonna stick with this, and this is the day.

If we go down in flames, we're okay with it. We made the, we made this decision together, right? That, that is a place, but you can't do too much of that, right? Like- I think sometimes when he was asking me for my opinion, he was really just- ... thinking- Just having a conversation ... thinking out loud. Yeah. Just ha- just like, "Okay, this is my thinking, you know, w- what do you think?"

38:00 · What Andy Saw in Him

Yeah. And, uh, the thing about Andy is, um, like when I said, "Okay, I'll do this, you know, I'm gonna give you 90 days a year, five years, boom, see if we can win something by the time I turn 60," right? He just listened. There was like no reaction. I didn't know if he was enthusiastic about it or how he felt about it.

I think part of it was he'd had some disappointment with, uh, with some other tournament anglers who may have talked a big game and, you know, it didn't pan out. Um, I'm just guessing, but, uh, he had expressed some frustration with, with, with, with some anglers. I, I know he had a, an angler who just quit in the middle of a tour- just sort of burned out in the middle of a tournament.

Hmm. Which I could see happening, you know, just sort of got too much to his head. Um- What, what do you think he saw in you? But eventually he did come back and say, "Yeah, let's do it," and he was all in. Um- So what do you think he saw in you that made... I mean, he's making a commitment too. Like, that's what a, a lot of people don't understand- Yeah

is like, he could fish with a lot of different people. That's right. He's gonna fill those 90 days. So choosing to do it with a certain angler, you in this situation, he has to see something in you that says, "You know what? I think we could do it." What do you think he saw in you? Well, we had a good relationship because we'd been fishing together for many years, and I was always true to my word when I said I was coming down, you know, when I was coming down.

And, and I just talked about, you know, technique and, and, and tarpon fishing incessantly. And he knew I'd read all the books and I'd seen all the videos and, um, and he just knew I was really into it, and I don't think anybody had made that kind of a commitment to him before. Um, and I, I'm guessing that, that, that that's what made the difference.

And maybe he also felt like I was serious because I, I put a timeline on it, you know? Mm. Um, gonna give it five years and then... It wasn't just like, "Yeah, let's go out and win one," right? 'Cause I, I remember Andy Mill interviewing me for the Gold Cup and he said, "Why do you wanna do this? Do you just wanna, do you just wanna, you know, is it for the socialization?"

And I said, "No, I don't care about the socialization. I wanna win." And he said, "Yeah, yeah, I felt the same way." Um, and I was... I didn't know how he was gonna respond 'cause the way he asked the question almost made it sound like being there to just socialize was the right answer, but that's, that's not what I wanted.

Trick question. So in- Trick question. In- Yeah, that's what it felt like It was like a trick question. Exactly. In your book, you, it seemed to take some stories either from, uh, something that happened on your boat or something that you heard these different stories like we talked about. One of the things that I found interesting is, is your character Gavin said that a lost fish is never the guide's fault.

41:00 · A Lost Fish Is Never the Guide's Fault

Yeah. Is he right? Well, so yeah, that- ... that was based on a s- uh, a conversation, and it was tongue in cheek with a guide, uh, one of my first guides down there, Alan Finkelman, who said that, and he's got a very dry sense of humor. And he was half-joking, but I think there is some truth to that. Um, and, uh, of course it is, I think, uh...

You know, he would, he- if I ask him now, I'm sure he would say, "No, that's not totally true." But h- but his, his point about the knots was actually a good one that, you know, 'cause my response was, and I think it's in the book, "Well, what if the guide's knot breaks?" And his re- his response was immediately, he said, "Well, the angler should have tied the knot."

Mm. Did you tie your own knots? I did, but it's, I did, except Andy would not let me tie my own knots. I think he saw my knots and was like, "No, Will." So he did knot. Well, which did you have more confidence in? Which did you have more confidence in, your own? I have more confidence in Andy's. Okay. I have more confidence in Andy's.

I, I think, I think I've developed a lot of confidence in mine after testing them, uh, so much. But in terms of just, you know, uh, tying them on the fly under the pressure cooker of that, uh, of a tournament- Mm-hmm ... I had, um- Mm-hmm ... uh, more confidence in his. Yeah. And then another scenario was that the, the angler wanted to win for his guide and the- Yeah

43:00 · Winning for Your Guide

guide wanted to win for himself. Is that a situation that you have familiarity with, with your relationship with Andy? And when you, when you finally did win, did you win it for yourself or did you win it for Andy, or was it a combination of both? Well, uh, you know, I entered it for myself. Um, uh, but over time I obviously wanted to win it for myself too.

But I realized, I didn't realize at the beginning how important this is for the guides because it's their career. Yeah. Right? For the anglers, we just show up in the Keys and fish these tournaments and then go back to our lives. So for, for a guide, winning these tournaments can help their career. You know, it, um, gives them bragging rights in the community, and they live and work down there, so it's very different for them.

And when I realized that, then that gave me extra motivation or inspiration because to, to at least give it my all, right? Mm-hmm. I didn't want to be the weak link. I mean, I knew I was the weak link, but I wanted to be less weak. I wanted to be a str- a stronger link, um, because I, uh, I, I knew it was important for him.

Mm-hmm. And, um, and he's an excellent guide and I thought he deserved it, uh, particularly after these false starts that, that he had had in the past. Mm-hmm. I also thought it was interesting that you made one of the characters, Olivia, a former dancer. Is that from- Yeah, that was, um- ... recently? Where, how did you, how did you come up with that character?

45:00 · Creating Olivia

There were, there was a lot of inspiration there, but, um- ... from, from various quarters, some of which you may be able to guess. But, um, you know, there was that, that club s- that strip club, Woody's, there in Islamorada. I don't know if it's still there. I don't think so. But, um, uh, uh, I thought, you know, what if one of these girls were in these, one of these tournaments?

And, uh, Olivia's one of those characters where, uh, y- you, you sort of a, um, afterthought. At least that's how she started, and then she grew into one of the two most important characters in the book. And, um, she dovetailed well with Greg- Mm-hmm ... um, in their relationship, and also with Sonya, because she and Sonya are such different people.

Um, and, you know, it adds some color, right? Yeah. Um, uh, uh, to the story. But, uh, I heard a story once, um, about a guy in, uh, who was running a bait shop, um, down there who went to the strip clubs a lot. And, uh, a stripper moved in and he came home one day, and she'd taken everything in the house and thrown it in a U-Haul and disappeared.

And anyway- Sounds like a story in the Keys ... that kind of... What's that? That sounds like a story that could actually happen in the Keys. Right? And, um, uh, I- it just, you know, there, there's, it just provides for so much drama, I find. Mm-hmm. And then, you know, in Olivia's case, she, she was doing it out of desperation, and she obviously, you know, she, she made, she made good and she's a very impressive person.

46:00 · Writing and Tarpon Fishing Are Both a Grind

Um, and, uh, I, I just, I fell in love with her as a character. Mm. What, what's similar about writing a book like this and actually tarpon fishing in pursuit of, uh, winning a tournament? Oh, that is an excellent question. It's a, a marathon, not a sprint. Mm. And it's a grind. And yeah, you know, in tarpon fishing, and particularly in tournament fishing, there are some real highs and some real lows.

Um, but you just gotta keep moving forward with... Y- you know, you gotta stay focused for that next opportunity. And, um, and if you're not focused for that and waiting for that next opportunity despite the failure you just experienced, then you're gonna blow that next opportunity. And writing is similar. You gotta, your butt has to be in a chair, and you gotta keep writing whether you feel like it or not.

Hmm. You gotta approach it as a job- Yeah ... for example. Um, and I've found that the more I write, even when I don't feel like writing and I'm not, don't feel like, I don't feel inspired, and I'll write something and think, "This is just complete schlock," and I don't know what I'm doing, and, and I've felt that in tarpon fishing too, and I'm never gonna get any better.

And, uh, I don't know how to get better. And then I'll go to the gym, or in the case of writing, I'll go to the gym or I'll go fishing, come back, and then I'll have an epiphany. It's a breakthrough in the story that moves it to the next stage, right? Um, it's like any endeavor in life. To, um, to be good at it, you, you gotta buckle down.

48:00 · The 10-Minute Writing Trick

Did you have a schedule when you were writing? Yes. Um, I, uh, tried to do a little bit every day, at least four days a week. I- event- over time, I developed... I, I sort of pooh-poohed this idea of like, "Well, I'm gonna, I'm gonna write 20 hours a week at least." And I thought that was kinda silly, 'cause I thought really you should be focused on the quality and, and blah, blah, blah.

But really, if you don't give yourself those goals, um, you, you, you won't get it done. Um, and, um, one, one trick I taught myself was, uh, if I come home and I'm tired from working or whatever, and I'm like, "Ah, I don't, I haven't written at all today," and it's 6:00 and I really just wanna grab something to eat and veg out in front of the TV, I'd s- I'd tell myself, "I'm just gonna do it for 10 minutes."

Hmm. I'm just gonna sit down, you know, at the keyboard and just write for 10 minutes. That inevitably, without fail, without exception, turned into at least an hour, and sometimes two, four, six, eight. Mm. I remember one time I sat down 5:30. "Oh, Jesus. Okay, I'll give it 10 minutes." I wrote until 2:00 in the morning.

That's so interesting. When you don't want- You trick your brain, right? Yeah. And then it, all of a sudden you're in the zone and- And then when you're, when you get in that zone like that writing, is that where some of these characters come from, or do you start with the characters and you just don't know where they're gonna go or how they're gonna fit in?

50:00 · Pantsers, Plotters and Five Tournament Days

So, okay, uh, very excellent question. Um, and, uh, all of the above is what I would say. So there's, uh, basically, um, broadly speaking for writers, there's two kinds of writers. There are what they call pantsers, people who write by the seat of their pants. Stephen King is a famous example of that. And then there are plotters, and those people outline and plot, and some people will plot right down to every single chapter.

Hmm. You know, I've got these three plot points in the chapter. So they got a broader beginning to end, um, storyline, and each chapter they'll plot out. Other people, like Stephen King says if he knows what the ending is, he couldn't write the story- Hmm ... um, 'cause he would just be too bored. Whereas other people will write the last line first, and then they, you know, write towards that.

I'm more the Stephen King plotter, uh, pantser category, so I just start writing and, um, and I, so I started with Greg. But I did have ideas for other characters, um, but I didn't know how many teams there were gonna be, for example- Mm-hmm, mm-hmm ... so I first had to decide, okay, I'm gonna have five teams. All right, who's on the teams?

You know, who are the guides, who are the anglers? And, and so as I got into it, it became more organized. The one part of Poontown that I did have to outline was the tournament chapter, chapters because it's five teams over five days, so you have 25 days of fishing and you gotta have a story arc for each team.

So that I had to, that I had to plot out. Mm-hmm. Um, but I still didn't know how it was gonna end. Um, and I wrote the prologue first, but the epilogue didn't come along until much later when I thought, oh, the, the, this epilogue fits in as like a bookend, right? And my third book, I have an idea for how it gets started.

I have no idea what's gonna happen in the middle. I have no idea how it's... So it just depends. But as you know, so, uh, uh, to be, but to be a little bit more specific with respect to your questions, I took notes. I have over 700 days on the water tarpon fishing. I took notes for every single day, the weather, what we caught, where we fished, who the guide was obviously, you know, where we launched, blah, blah, blah.

52:00 · 700 Days of Notes

And then what animals we saw, what wildlife we saw, um, and what stories I heard. So I had all these ideas, all these anecdotes, including characters swirling around in my head, and then I met all these people, right? And all these, you know, there's so many characters down there, right? Um- Yeah ... and I mean, God bless it.

It's like a soap opera on the water, right? Um- And, uh, one reason I took the story out of the Keys, uh, was because the Keys itself has such a strong personality and it's its own character. I didn't want it to interfere with the s- the themes of obsession and just the feeling of catching tarpon and tournament fishing.

Mm-hmm. It's interesting. When you took all the- That's probably far more information than you need to know. Well, no, no, it's, it's inter- I just think it's interesting how, how it all comes together. Um, when you took all these notes when you're, you know, on day three of the 700 that you, that you've taken notes for, what

Did you ever have the idea, like, "I'm taking these notes because I might wanna write something about this one day"? Or- No ... taking notes, but can you- I just took the notes because it was such a strong, uh, steep learning curve. I wanted to write it all down because I knew I only had, at that time, you know, two days on the water.

The next year it'd be three or whatever. And so I wanted to be able to review them before I went down on my next trip so I wasn't starting from zero again. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. That's how it started. That's cool. Um, and then I found it interesting, too, that you start this book in 50 years in the future. Yeah.

54:00 · Starting 50 Years in the Future

Like, where did you come up with that, and like, why, why was fishing banned? Well, I don't know if it's gonna be banned, but, you know, there's d- with animal rights activists and just the way of the world and, um, and our culture, uh, that was just sort of a, a... The, the, the idea, one of the themes is loss, right?

Mm-hmm. And, uh, the idea was, uh, that this guy hadn't tournament fished for decades. Um, and he went with his family down to the Tequesta Islands, um, the Tequesta Isles, excuse me, which are the Keys, basically. And, uh, he snuck off. He's very old at this point, and he snuck off and went to this old little fishing museum, and he saw the dusty trophy from the Sabalo Cup with the, the names on the base, and he- they're all grimy with dust and rust, and he rubbed off a couple of the sets of names, you know, one guide and one angler each.

And that's when this flood of memories comes back, and then you go back 50 years to, you know, when the tournament was still taking place. And part of what triggered that, Tom, is, is what I've seen going on in the Keys for the last 25 years, which is not that long. Mm-hmm. You know, I remember when I first went down there, people said, "Oh, you should have been here in the '60s, right?"

Mm-hmm. And now it's like, "Oh, you should have been here in the early 2000s, right?" Um, and I just saw the way the fishery was headed. And of course, you hear it from the guides. All the guides are concerned, right? And there's no one reason why it's in decline. Um, so that was just me sort of looking back at my own career, and I thought it was an interesting way to start Yeah, it was.

Uh, it, it captured my interest right away. Um, I thought- And it ends, it, it, the, the epilogue is back 50 years in the future, and that's, that's how it ends too. It's sort of, like I say, the bookends to the story. That's cool. I wanna ask you, um, one final question here, and that is, you fished as just a angler coming down, just ha- trying to have a good time tarpon fishing.

56:00 · What Winning Actually Felt Like

Obviously, it was, it, it had a big impact on you. Then you go to, "Okay, I'm going to commit a lot of time and a lot of energy and a lot of money, and my goal is to win one of these tournaments." You obviously fished in a lot of other tour- a lot more tournaments than you won, so you didn't win- Right ... most of them, right?

And so- Yes, correct ... but you do win with Andy Thompson. You win the biggest- Right ... one there is. What is the difference between winning one of these tournaments and participating in one of these tournaments, or having a good showing in one of these tournaments? What is the difference?

Well, the The journey is better than the destination. Um, and the journey would've been wonderful without winning. Um, but winning, first of all, going back to your earlier question, I was so happy for Andy and, uh, 'cause I, I generally ... And, and relieved because I, I, I felt surpr- he was putting me on fish every day.

Mm-hmm. Right? And, uh, so there are some tournaments we should have won, um, and it's, it's clear why we didn't win, and it wasn't Andy. Um, and, um, but I, I just felt, uh ... It was a sense of accomplishment, but also what flooded over me was gratitude, which I didn't expect. I was just, I felt like the luckiest human being in the world that I was able to go down there for 90 days a year, year after year- And compete in this sport that, let's face it, you know, only 27 of us care about, right?

Mm-hmm. And, uh, and, uh, it's not a big money tournament. It's like, you know how it is. People ask me, "Is there a lot of money in those tournaments?" I say, "Yes, and it's all going out." Right? It's not like a Bass Tournament, 'cause you're not making a living doing this, right? But I was able to go... You know the people who are competing in these things.

I mean, these people could be doing anything they wanted, right, with their lives. These heart surgeons, and captains of industry, and trust fund people, and, and yet they, they're obsessed with this sport, as I was. And I was able to put everything into that, right, without worrying about how I was gonna make a living.

And so I, I... It was just sort of unb- the whole experience was just unbelievable to me that I'd been able to do this and then actually win. Um, so it was, I, it was not what I felt, it was not what... I didn't feel how I thought I would feel. Mm. You know? I thought I'd feel like, "Yeah, kick ass." That's not how I felt.

And, uh, that, which was really interesting. It's kinda like, uh, it reminds me of that, I don't know why I'm thinking of this, but there's that line at the end of 92 in the Shade, the very end, spoiler alert, where the one, the older guy shoots the younger guy in the, guy in the chest and, and, uh, Thomas McGuane writes, "And he didn't feel like he thought he would when he got shot," or something.

He doesn't explain how he felt getting shot. He just says he didn't feel how he thought he would. And that's sort of how I felt. It's like I didn't expect to f- feel this overwhelming sense of gratitude, um, as well as a sense of accomplishment, I would say. Uh, so that was a surprise. So do you feel like you need to do that again?

1:01:00 · Hanging Up the Rod

No. No, I mean, I would love to compete, um, again, um, but I only wanna do it if I can win. Uh, I'm trying, I've caught some records, world records, and I think that that's something that I can continue to focus on, you know, as a goal. But I, I fished with David Delue, I've fished with Andy Mill, I've, I've fished with Nathaniel Lindell.

I've seen how good these guys are and, um, you know, it's like playing basketball with Michael Jordan. Um, and, and at 65, you know, you can lie to your- so you can go to the gym all day, you know, you can do everything you, you, you can to be the best that you can, but 65 is 65, and if you're competing against somebody who's 48...

I remember Eizo telling me that he won his last tournament at 48 or 49, and he felt like he was in the prime- Hmm ... of his competing career at the time. I mean, your eyesight's not as good, your hand-eye coordination's not as good, your reflexes are not as good. You're not as responsive, at least, I don't know, maybe those are just excuses, but- Well, but in a- I, like I say, I wanna win.

If I don't see a path- In a lot of ways, you have more experience and you- You do ... more knowledge, and you have a better- Yeah ... guide re- guide-angler relationship, and there'll, there will be some years, I think, where that will outweigh the, the de- degradation of your physical skills to a point to where it won't, and that's, that's where- Yeah, right

it's a hard decision. Yes, exactly. You know, like, i- there, you always hear, like, athletes, they want, they wanna be an old man in a young man's body because they want the s- the knowledge and the experience and the, the, the things that they've learned, but then they want it. If you had that in a young man's body, you're gonna be amazing, right?

And this, this sport in particular is incredibly physical, and, uh, you know, it, it's a- Yeah ... it's such a small community of people that knows how physical it is and how demanding it is and how competitive it is, and for what? Like, that's, that's also super interesting is, like, it's not, you're not winning millions of dollars.

You're spending millions of dollars. Like, just like you said- Yep ... it's, it's all going out, but somehow it is the biggest thing in the world to the people that are there. And, and it's- Yeah ... just really cool that, that you wrote this book and the way that you wrote it. I, I think that it's, it's really cool.

Really cool. Thank you very much. So good job. I would not change the experience, uh, for, for anything. Um, and, uh, I, when I did say I was hanging up my rod, so to speak, um, I, I was very- Uh, the, the response was very gratifying. Uh, Andy Thompson said, "No, man, I wanna win. I wanna win with you," and that was very thoughtful.

But I, I think he can... He's still young, he can continue to win, and, and, uh, he just needs the right angler. And then Mike Criscola called me and said, "You, you shouldn't, you shouldn't quit. You should continue," and I just... That meant so much to me. But every, every person has to know... What, what did Clint Eastwood say?

"A man's got to know his limitations." Um, and, uh, you know, I just figured it was time. Well, yeah, I think going out, going out win- on your terms is, is something that's very important. Um, and seems like that's what you did, and then now you're- you have this other career. How many books have you written? Uh, this is my second.

1:04:00 · The Next Book

Second? Yeah. And you have a third on the way? I have a third I'm working on, yeah. And it... Will that be about tarpon fishing? No, my first one is a legal thriller. It's a technology legal thriller, um, that takes place a lot of it in Japan, and, and the third one's a sequel to that. Um- Okay ... which I wasn't gonna write, but, um, I had an epiphany about it, so.

All right. I'm ex- I'm excited about that one actually. So does this writing career get you as excited as your legal career or your tarpon fishing career? It does at times. It does at times, uh, get me super stoked. In, in fact, at this point I'm, I'm sort of wondering how many books I can write, you know, before the inevitable.

Um, and it's nice to be motivated like that, right? Mm-hmm. And, um, it's, um... I, I... When I, when I receive comments from people, like about this book, um, including your comment, I've received, uh, some great com- wonderful comments from guides and, um, and other tournament anglers, and that just means the world to me.

Yeah. Far more important than the, the sales, for example. Um- Well, you got it right. I mean, you touched on a lot of things that, that other books have tried to do, and some have done it well, like the guide-angler relationship. That's been documented pretty, pretty well with some Monte Burke's books and some of the other ones that, that, that he really goes into that.

But there, there are things about, about yours that I haven't seen in other books, so it's really, really good. Thank you very much for saying that. That means a lot coming from you, Tom. Yeah. Well, thanks. Um, well, I appreciate you being here, and, uh, it's nice to, nice to meet you in person, or kind of in person.

But, uh- ... good luck with, with all your... with this book and, and, uh, the ones that you're writing. I'm sure they'll be very successful. My pleasure. Thank you so much. All right. Thank you. All right. We'll be back next week with another great guest.

Listen to this Episode

Subscribe to the Tom Rowland Podcast

Listen on Apple Podcasts Listen on Spotify

Never Miss an Episode

Subscribe to get the latest episodes, show notes, and exclusive content delivered straight to your inbox.

{"@context": "https://schema.org", "@graph": [{"@type": "VideoObject", "name": "Mark Weeks: Poontown, Tarpon Tournaments and Quitting Law to Win One", "description": "Novelist and former lawyer Mark Weeks on Poontown, leaving his practice at 56 to chase tarpon tournaments, and what winning with guide Andy Thompson felt like.", "thumbnailUrl": "https://i.ytimg.com/vi/g6jp4D2VkpI/maxresdefault.jpg", "uploadDate": "2026-11-17", "embedUrl": "https://www.youtube.com/embed/g6jp4D2VkpI", "contentUrl": "https://youtu.be/g6jp4D2VkpI", "publisher": {"@type": "Organization", "name": "Tom Rowland Podcast", "url": "https://www.tomrowlandpodcast.com"}}, {"@type": "PodcastEpisode", "name": "Mark Weeks: Poontown, Tarpon Tournaments and Quitting Law to Win One", "episodeNumber": 1036, "datePublished": "2026-11-17", "description": "Novelist and former lawyer Mark Weeks on Poontown, leaving his practice at 56 to chase tarpon tournaments, and what winning with guide Andy Thompson felt like.", "url": "https://www.tomrowlandpodcast.com/episodes/mark-weeks-poontown-tarpon-tournaments-ep-1036", "associatedMedia": {"@type": "MediaObject", "contentUrl": "https://playlist.megaphone.fm?e=WPCM6192416636"}, "author": {"@type": "Person", "name": "Tom Rowland"}, "partOfSeries": {"@type": "PodcastSeries", "name": "Tom Rowland Podcast", "url": "https://www.tomrowlandpodcast.com"}}, {"@type": "Article", "headline": "Mark Weeks: Poontown, Tarpon Tournaments and Quitting Law to Win One", "description": "Novelist and former lawyer Mark Weeks on Poontown, leaving his practice at 56 to chase tarpon tournaments, and what winning with guide Andy Thompson felt like.", "datePublished": "2026-11-17", "dateModified": "2026-11-17", "author": {"@type": "Person", "name": "Tom Rowland"}, "publisher": {"@type": "Organization", "name": "Tom Rowland Podcast", "url": "https://www.tomrowlandpodcast.com"}, "mainEntityOfPage": "https://www.tomrowlandpodcast.com/episodes/mark-weeks-poontown-tarpon-tournaments-ep-1036", "image": "https://i.ytimg.com/vi/g6jp4D2VkpI/maxresdefault.jpg", "about": {"@type": "Person", "name": "Mark Weeks", "jobTitle": "Novelist and former international lawyer"}}, {"@type": "FAQPage", "mainEntity": [{"@type": "Question", "name": "What is Poontown by Mark Weeks about?", "acceptedAnswer": {"@type": "Answer", "text": "Poontown is a novel about tarpon fly fishing and the obsession that comes with it. It follows five angler and guide teams over five days as they compete for the Sabalo Cup, a fictional tournament that sits at the top of a pyramid of elite events, so a team has to win one of the other big tournaments before it can be invited. The story opens fifty years in the future, when an old angler finds a dusty Sabalo Cup trophy in a small fishing museum, and then goes back to the season the tournament still ran."}}, {"@type": "Question", "name": "Is Poontown a true story?", "acceptedAnswer": {"@type": "Answer", "text": "No. The disclaimer in the book says only the fish are real. Mark takes a kernel from real experiences on the water and stories he heard on the skiff, then builds fiction around it. He moved the setting out of the Keys and the Everglades into an invented place inspired by them, because he felt the Keys have such a strong personality that they would compete with the story he wanted to tell about the fish and the people who chase them."}}, {"@type": "Question", "name": "Why is Poontown modeled on Neverland and Peter Pan?", "acceptedAnswer": {"@type": "Answer", "text": "Mark read Bob Rich's description of Andy Mill as Peter Pan and thought it fit tarpon season perfectly. During the season, everyone is a lost boy chasing the same thing, the days melt together, and nobody cares what is happening in the rest of the world. He went back and read the 1910 version of Peter Pan and found so many lines that matched life in the Keys that he used them as the epigraph for each chapter."}}, {"@type": "Question", "name": "How do you get invited to a major invitational tarpon tournament?", "acceptedAnswer": {"@type": "Answer", "text": "Mark chaired the Don Hawley Tarpon Tournament for two years, and he says the waiting lists for the major events are long. The committee looks for the teams most likely to compete hard, because the tournament's proceeds support the Guides Trust Foundation and the event needs serious anglers to keep going. It helps to have won another tournament, to have guides and other anglers vouch for your skills, and to be known as trustworthy, because the sport relies on the honesty of the people in it. Committees also look closely at who the guide is."}}, {"@type": "Question", "name": "How physical is tarpon tournament fishing for the angler?", "acceptedAnswer": {"@type": "Answer", "text": "Mark says it is far more physical than most people expect. He started competing at 56 and changed how he treated his body completely, going to the gym every day in the off-season, watching his diet, skipping alcohol during the season and getting at least seven hours of sleep. Anglers stand on the bow from early morning into the afternoon with nothing to lean on, eat on the run and have to stay sharp enough to react the moment a fish shows up, often for five tournament days in a row."}}, {"@type": "Question", "name": "Why does the guide matter so much in tarpon tournaments?", "acceptedAnswer": {"@type": "Answer", "text": "Mark believes the guide is the most important tool in the angler's toolbox. In his view, an excellent guide can lead a mediocre angler to a win far more often than the other way around, and he knows of only one rare case where a top angler essentially guided an out-of-town guide to victory. That is why tournament committees often ask who the guide is before they look at the angler."}}]}]}