Reef fishing for snappers means anchoring up-current of a chummed reef, keeping a steady chum slick to hold the fish, and setting your depth based on the species you want, so yellowtail and mangrove snappers come to your boat instead of the boat next to you. In this How 2 Tuesday I sit down with Captain Scott Walker to cover the do's and don'ts of working a Florida Keys reef, why chum is the whole game, and how to pick your spot without getting yelled at.
Listen now: press play in the player above and follow along.
You run out to the reef, anchor with courtesy among the other boats, and set a steady chum slick to hold the snappers behind your boat. Your target species sets your depth: yellowtail snappers hold in roughly 35 to 90 feet on the edge of the reef, while mangrove snappers sit inside that, on rock piles closer to shore. The more chum you put out, the more action you get. Scott walks through his exact approach in the episode.
Chum is what holds the fish on the reef and brings them to your boat. Scott's number one mistake he sees is anglers not taking enough of it. If you only bring two boxes and the boat next to you brings twenty, the fish go to them the moment you run out. He recommends a dedicated cooler packed with seven-pound blocks, as many as you can hold, and reminds you that you can refreeze whatever you do not use. As he puts it, chum and they will come.
Keep a reasonable distance, about 50 to 75 yards, and set your anchor out in front of your boat so that when you come tight you are stern to stern with the others. The mistake is anchoring up in front of someone's bow and pulling their fish under their boat to you. Get all the sterns lined up and you will never get yelled at. Scott explains the etiquette in the episode.
Your target species sets your depth. For yellowtail snapper, fish the edge of the reef in roughly 35 to 90 feet. For mangrove snapper, fish inside of that on hard rock piles with a little grass and sand, sometimes as close as one to two miles off the beach in Hawk's Channel. Chum the rocks and the mangroves will show up. Scott covers how he picks his spots in the episode.
Not taking enough chum. Anglers invest in gas, time, and vacation, then try to save a few dollars on chum and wonder why they caught three or four fish while the next boat caught thirty. Spend the extra money, bring a dedicated cooler full of blocks, and keep the slick going. As you use chum you free up cooler space to start putting fish on ice. Scott drives this point home in the episode.
Captain Scott Walker has spent his life on the water in the Florida Keys, and when it comes to reef fishing for snappers he has the details dialed in that most anglers never think about. I wanted him on because reef fishing looks simple from the outside, run out, drop a bait, but the difference between three fish and thirty comes down to chum, courtesy, and depth. Scott explains all of it in plain language in the episode, so press play in the player above.
The Keys reefs are only about four miles out and easy to access, so on a good day there are a lot of boats lined up. The first rule is courtesy. Come in, but keep a reasonable distance and set your anchor out in front so you end up stern to stern with everyone else, not pulling fish out from under someone's bow. Get the sterns lined up and you will never get yelled at. Scott explains the etiquette in the episode, so press play in the player above.
The single biggest mistake Scott sees is anglers not taking enough chum. The reef holds fish, but the chum slick is what keeps them behind your boat. Run out and the whole school slides over to the boat next door. He runs a dedicated cooler packed with seven-pound blocks, as many as he can hold, and reminds you that you can refreeze what you do not use. Hear how he manages his chum all day in the episode, so press play in the player above.
You do not fish the reef randomly, you fish for a species and that sets your depth. Yellowtail snapper come into sight first on the edge of the reef, roughly 35 to 90 feet. Mangrove snapper hold inside that, on hard rock piles with grass and sand, sometimes a mile or two off the beach in Hawk's Channel. Pick the fish you want and the depth follows. Scott breaks down how he chooses in the episode, so press play in the player above.
For mangroves you are hunting hard bottom, rock with a little grass and sand, and that takes a little homework. Scott leans on local charter boats and his charts to locate productive rock piles close to the beach, then chums them up. Wherever you find that hard structure, the mangroves will be there. He explains how he scouts new rocks in the episode, so press play in the player above.
Reef fishing for snappers is one of those things that rewards the angler who sweats the details. Courtesy keeps the peace, chum keeps the fish, and depth keeps you on the right species.
Next time you run to the reef, take more chum than you think you need and line your stern up with the fleet. Do those two things and your day changes. Press play in the player above to hear Scott's full breakdown.
Captain Scott Walker · Into the Blue · Florida Keys · yellowtail snapper · mangrove snapper · reef fishing · chum · Hawk's Channel · How 2 Tuesday · Tom Rowland Podcast · Saltwater Experience
How 2 Tuesday is my weekly series where I break down one fishing skill at a time, from knots and casting to gear, tactics, and the habits that make you a better angler. Watch and listen to every How 2 Tuesday episode from Tom Rowland.
Captain Scott Walker runs Into the Blue and is one of the most respected charter captains in the Florida Keys, known for his deep reef and offshore knowledge and his straightforward, practical instruction. He is a frequent How 2 Tuesday guest, walking anglers through the tactics and electronics that put more fish in the boat.
Subscribe to get the latest episodes, show notes, and exclusive content delivered straight to your inbox.