Choosing between a bay boat and a skiff comes down to one trade-off: a skiff gets you into the shallowest, most technical water for poling tailing fish, while a bay boat gives you range, big live wells, family comfort, higher sides, and a hardtop you can sight fish from. There is no do-everything boat at any price, so the right pick is the one that matches how you actually fish. In this How 2 Tuesday my friend Mike Larkin and I work through the decision the way I help anglers do it at the Miami Boat Show.
Watch now: press play on the video above and follow along.
It depends entirely on how you fish and who you fish with. A skiff is the better choice if your top priority is getting into the shallowest water possible, poling for tailing permit, tarpon, and redfish, and slipping under low bridges. A bay boat wins if you want range, big live wells, a more comfortable and family friendly ride, higher sides for kids, and a hardtop you can stand on to sight fish. Every boat is a compromise, so the right answer is the boat that fits your real days on the water.
Yes. Tom has caught many bonefish, permit, tarpon, and redfish off a trolling motor. The trick is running it on low so the prop stays fully submerged and never cavitates, which can actually be quieter than poling because a push pole makes noise every time it touches bottom. The catch is that to keep the whole prop underwater you cannot go as shallow as you can while poling, so for true tailing depth a skiff still has the edge.
A skiff is a specialized, technical boat. It needs a buddy who can pole, since chasing fish solo can be miserable. The low sides are a safety concern with kids, the live wells and storage are small, and there is no shade. Battery weight for a trolling motor has to be balanced carefully, and adding a third person can sink a small skiff so much that it no longer floats shallower than a bay boat. It is a fantastic tool for one job, but it asks you to give up comfort and versatility.
A bay boat has higher sides, a larger cockpit, and a more comfortable ride in chop, which matters with a spouse and kids aboard. The big live well doubles as the best entertainment on the boat, a personal aquarium the kids watch all day. There is room for more batteries without hurting performance, plus a hardtop you can stand on to sight fish 20 feet in the air instead of about four feet on a skiff. It also lets you mix fishing with the beach and water skiing.
Stopping the boat is as important as moving it. In wind, a single anchor point lets the bow blow 50 feet off the fish and out of casting range. Two power poles hold the boat's attitude so it stays put and pointed where Tom wants it. He can run the trolling motor and both power poles by remote from the tower. Trolling motors do have reverse, but it is incredibly loud and tricky, so the power poles are the better way to lock the boat down.
Match the boat to your tow vehicle and your storage. Tom's F-150 pulled his 24 footer fine and he later moved to an F-250, but the real constraint is often garage and driveway storage, where swing-away tongue trailers help. More boat also means more systems, power pole wiring, trolling motor, electronics, radar, and in saltwater every added system is one more thing that can fail. Tom's guest Mike Larkin, weighing a Luna bay boat for his family, found the 22 may fit his tow capacity and trailering better than the 24.
My friend Mike Larkin came to me with the same question I field constantly, especially heading into the Miami Boat Show: skiff or bay boat? Mike grew up on an 18 foot skiff in Miami and loves the quietness and dexterity, but he has moved to the Tampa area where everyone runs a trolling motor, and he is weighing a bay boat for his wife and two kids. His situation is a perfect case study, because the answer is never the same for two anglers. I dig into his specifics in the episode, so watch the video above.
Mike assumed a trolling motor meant parking on spots rather than hunting, and that is the most common misconception I hear. The truth is you can absolutely stalk bonefish, permit, tarpon, and redfish off a trolling motor if you run it low with the prop fully submerged so it never cavitates. A push pole makes noise every time it touches bottom, and I have a theory that the last sound a wise old fish hears before getting caught is that pole sliding across the grass. I explain the technique in the video above.
A skiff is a beautiful, specialized tool, but it asks for sacrifices. You need a buddy who can pole, the low sides are a real concern with kids, storage and live wells are small, and there is no shade. Add a third person and a small skiff can sink enough that it no longer floats shallower than a bay boat. I lay out the full pros and cons list with Mike in the episode, so press play above.
One thing newer boat buyers overlook is how you hold position. In wind, a boat that blows 50 feet off the fish has taken you out of casting range no matter how quietly you approached. That is why I run two power poles to hold the boat's attitude, all controlled by remote from the tower along with the trolling motor. I walk through how I set that up in the video above.
Here is the way I help anglers work through this decision. None of it is about which boat is better, only which is better for you.
Watch Mike and me work through the full decision in the video above.
Every boat is a compromise, and the worst thing you can do is buy the wrong one for your real days on the water. The best boat is the one you use constantly, because guide boats that run 300 days a year stay dialed in while neglected boats fall apart.
Name your priority, be honest about who fishes with you, and match the boat to your truck and your garage. Do that and the choice gets a lot clearer. Watch the video above and follow along.
bay boat · skiff · Mike Larkin · trolling motor · push pole · power pole · Yellowfin · Lowrance ActiveTarget · bonefish · permit · tarpon · redfish · Miami Boat Show · Luna bay boat · How 2 Tuesday
How 2 Tuesday is my weekly series where I break down one fishing skill at a time, from knots and casting to gear, tactics, and the habits that make you a better angler. Watch and listen to every How 2 Tuesday episode from Tom Rowland.
I'm Tom Rowland, a professional fishing guide based in the Florida Keys, host of the Tom Rowland Podcast, and the longtime host of the Saltwater Experience television show. On the podcast's How 2 Tuesday series I break down one practical skill or lesson at a time, from fishing technique and gear to the habits that make you a better angler, in short, focused episodes you can put to use right away.
Subscribe to get the latest episodes, show notes, and exclusive content delivered straight to your inbox.