Going from a recreational athlete to a competitive one means following a structured program and paying attention to the small details — transitions, efficiency, and the mindset to keep improving week over week. In part two of my Mindset of a Champion series on Physical Friday, I talk with three-time CrossFit Games Masters champion Kevin Koester about the exact shift that takes you from just getting your workouts in to actually competing in your age group, a local CrossFit competition, a triathlon, or a Spartan race.
Listen now: press play in the player above and follow along.
You start following a real program built by a coach who knows what they are doing, and then you execute it. Kevin Koester told me the recreational athlete just shows up and gets their workout in, but the competitor follows progressive programming — working at 75 percent on a workout this week, then 77 percent on the same workout next week. That structured progression is how you make measurable gains instead of just staying busy.
The shift is that you start thinking about everything in the workout, not just the movements. Kevin pointed to transitions and movement efficiency as the difference between the member population and the competitor. The recreational athlete is not thinking about how to move between exercises faster or how to do the same work with less wasted motion. The competitor is asking how to beat last round's time without working any harder.
Because that is where races and competitions are won or lost. In CrossFit it is the seconds you lose moving between movements. In a triathlon it is the transition from swim to bike to run. The fitness is only part of it — the athlete who has dialed in the little details ends up ahead of someone who is in equal or better shape but leaves time on the table. Paying attention to those details is the competitive mindset.
Following a program designed by a coach who knows what they are doing is the single most important step Kevin and I both pointed to. You can be consistent on your own, but to make the jump to competitive you need progressive programming that pushes you at the right percentages and builds on itself. A good program takes the guesswork out and lets you focus on execution.
Yes. The competitive mindset transfers to anything — triathlon, a Spartan race, a fishing tournament, or a goal at work. The pattern is the same: get consistent first, then follow a structured plan, then sweat the small competitive details that most people ignore. That is how you take something you are already decent at and push it to the next level.
Kevin Koester is a multiple-time CrossFit Games Masters champion and an Invictus athlete who follows Invictus Masters programming. He is the guest in this Mindset of a Champion series, and he first appeared in full on episode 774 of the Tom Rowland Podcast, where he shared his story and a lot of training advice worth going back to hear.
I am not a CrossFit Games champion, so when I want to understand how someone takes the leap from recreational to elite, I go ask a person who has actually done it. Kevin Koester has won at the highest level of his sport, and I knew his answer would translate far beyond the gym. The whole point of Mindset of a Champion is to borrow the tactics of people who have won something and apply them to whatever you are chasing.
A lot of people are already off the couch and in pretty good shape, and they start wondering whether they could do a race, an event, or a local competition. Kevin laid out two things that have to change. The first is following a real program. The second is a mental shift toward the details. I break down both with him in this episode, and the second one surprised me. Press play to hear exactly how he thinks through a workout differently than everyone else.
Kevin described doing a three-minute interval for five rounds and obsessing over one question — how do I beat two minutes on the next round without working any harder? That is efficiency thinking, and it is the same reason triathlons are won in the transition area and fishing tournaments are won by the guide who wastes no motion. I connect his CrossFit example to the way I approach competitive fishing in the full episode. Listen in to hear how the same principle shows up everywhere.
The day after recording this, what stuck with me was how simple Kevin made it sound. Get consistent, follow a smart program, then care about the details nobody else cares about. That is the whole jump.
You already have the consistency down. Now you are looking to upgrade. Kevin's tips are the upgrade. Go back and hear his full story on episode 774, then put this into your own training.
Physical Friday is my weekly fitness series for fishing guides, anglers, hunters, and outdoorsmen — the training, nutrition, and mindset to stay in the game for life. Watch and listen to every Physical Friday episode from Tom Rowland.
Kevin Koester · CrossFit Games · Invictus · Invictus Masters · CrossFit Open · Spartan race · triathlon · Bassmaster Classic · competitive fishing · Physical Friday · Tom Rowland Podcast · episode 774
I'm Tom Rowland, a professional fishing guide based in the Florida Keys, host of the Tom Rowland Podcast, and the longtime host of the Saltwater Experience television show. Physical Friday is my weekly fitness series where I help fishing guides, anglers, hunters, and outdoorsmen build the training, nutrition, and mindset to stay strong and stay in the game for life.
Subscribe to get the latest episodes, show notes, and exclusive content delivered straight to your inbox.